Latest
Remembering Shyam Benegal: A prolific career spanning a wide array of films
Shyam Benegal is known for making path-breaking films such as Ankur, Manthan, Bhumika, Junoon, Manthan and more.

Published
2 months agoon
By
CB Desk
By Girish Wankhede
Life offers us a vast tapestry of options and opportunities to express our individuality, akin to the grandeur of royalty, allowing us to showcase our unique talents and expertise. In this expansive landscape, it becomes imperative to focus on our skills and strengths, channelling our energy into a specific domain that resonates with our personal inclinations and our understanding of the societal fabric that envelops us. In this context, art serves as a mirror, reflecting our insights and the profound significance we derive from our lived experiences.
Among the rare luminaries in the realm of cinema, Shyam Benegal stands out as a filmmaker endowed with an extraordinary ability to navigate the intricate realities of various social issues. His acute awareness of the struggles faced by the masses, the exploitation they endured, and the complex dynamics that governed their lives allowed him to craft narratives that were both poignant and impactful. Drawing inspiration from the great masters of global cinema, including Federico Fellini and Satyajit Ray, Benegal forged his own distinctive style, ultimately creating some of the most memorable films in the rich tapestry of Indian cinema.
His prolific career spanned a wide array of mediums, including feature films, documentaries, short films, and television productions, establishing him as a revered authority in the realm of modern communication. Benegal dedicated himself to mentoring emerging filmmakers, embodying a profound sense of integrity and social commitment. His extensive body of work is a testament to this dedication, encompassing films that engage with pressing social issues, biographies, explorations of Indian culture, themes of women’s empowerment, and incisive socio-political commentaries. This remarkable oeuvre represents a revolution of the highest order, redefining the boundaries of Indian cinema.
Also read: Shah Rukh Khan: “I am of the opinion that films are not as important as my own life”
Benegal’s films epitomize substance, integrity, and style, serving as invaluable case studies for generations of filmmakers to come. He captured the very essence of what it means to be a filmmaker, addressing critical issues while engaging with an intellectual audience that had grown weary of the conventional dance dramas and melodramatic narratives that dominated mainstream cinema. By delving into more nuanced and complex topics, he dissected various societal segments with a depth that transcended the constraints of time, creating works that remain relevant and resonant.
Reflecting on the evolution of Indian cinema, it becomes evident that the Indian parallel film movement, often referred to as Art House Cinema, drew profound inspiration from the Italian Neorealism movement. This cinematic approach emerged in the aftermath of World War II, characterized by filmmakers who sought to tell authentic stories set against the backdrop of real locations and featuring working-class individuals, many of whom were non-professional actors. This movement served as a powerful voice for independent filmmakers, who had experienced the ravages of exploitation during the war, resonating deeply with audiences seeking genuine narratives.
Italian masters such as Roberto Rossellini, Federico Fellini, and Vittorio De Sica made significant contributions to this genre, crafting films rich in social commentary and human emotion. De Sica’s seminal work, “Bicycle Thieves,” in particular, left an indelible mark on Indian filmmakers, inspiring them to explore the lives and struggles of the working class rather than adhering to the conventional tropes of melodrama that dominated mainstream cinema. This shift toward issue-based storytelling can be traced back to early pioneers like Baburao Painter, who, as early as 1925, produced a silent film titled “Savkaari Paash.”
Also read: When Rajesh Khanna realized that he was not God but Dog
In the decades that followed, filmmakers such as V. Shantaram with “Duniya Na Mane” and Chetan Anand with “Neecha Nagar” began to carve out a niche for socially relevant cinema. However, it was Satyajit Ray who truly revolutionized Indian filmmaking with his iconic Appu trilogy: “Pather Panchali,” “Aparajito,” and “Apur Sansar.” Ray’s work not only set a new standard for storytelling but also profoundly influenced subsequent generations of filmmakers, including the likes of Shyam Benegal, Adoor Gopalakrishnan and Girish Kasaravalli. Among these luminaries, Shyam Benegal emerged as a prominent figure, deeply influenced by Ray’s artistry. His admiration for Ray was so profound that he even produced a documentary chronicling Ray’s life and work.
Benegal’s films resonate with the same ethos as those of Bimal Roy, Hrishikesh Mukherjee, Basu Chatterjee, and Ritwik Ghatak, all of whom shared a commitment to issue-based narratives that combined entertainment with social relevance. His cinematic journey has spanned a remarkable array of themes and styles, seamlessly blending the series with the engaging, captivating audiences with his innovative storytelling.
His extensive body of work is a testament to his ability to evoke a spectrum of emotions—surprise, amusement, and introspection—through his films. Each project reflects his keen understanding of the human condition, as he masterfully navigates complex social issues while maintaining a narrative that is both accessible and thought-provoking. In doing so, Shyam Benegal has not only enriched Indian cinema but has also solidified his legacy as a filmmaker who has consistently pushed the boundaries of storytelling, making significant contributions to the art of cinema that will resonate for generations to come.
Also read: When Jaya Bachchan said, “Amit did not force me to quit films”
Benegal’s illustrious career began modestly as a copywriter in an advertising agency, yet his passion for storytelling soon led him to create his first documentary film in Gujarati, titled “Ghar Bete Ganga” (Ganges at the Door), in 1962. This initial foray into filmmaking paved the way for his groundbreaking feature debut, “Ankur,” which marked the introduction of renowned actors Anand Nag and Shabana Azmi to Indian cinema. “Ankur,” inspired by real events from the 1950s in his hometown of Hyderabad, was crafted with a distinct neorealist approach, echoing the Italian cinematic style. The film intricately explored the lives of two characters from the Dalit community, delving into their struggles and obsessions while also addressing themes of class conflict, caste dynamics, and the complex parent-child relationships.
Following the success of “Ankur,” Benegal directed “Nishant,” based on an original screenplay by the acclaimed playwright Vijay Tendulkar, with dialogues penned by Satya Dev Dubey. This film boasted an impressive ensemble cast, including Girish Karnad, Amrish Puri, Shabana Azmi, Mohan Agashe, Anant Nag, Sadhu Meher, and Smita Patil. “Nishant” poignantly depicted the exploitation of villagers by landlords, highlighting the systemic caste oppression and capitalist exploitation that permeated rural India.
Benegal’s next significant work, “Manthan,” was inspired by the pioneering milk cooperative movement led by Verghese Kurien and was once again scripted by Vijay Tendulkar. This groundbreaking film was notable for its crowdfunding approach and ultimately won a National Award. It explored the struggles of local dairy owners and workers against corporate exploitation, emphasizing the community’s fight for dignity and fair treatment.
Also read: Iconic ‘tragedy-king’ Dilip Kumar loved to make people laugh, off-screen
In 1977, Benegal released “Bhumika,” a biographical film based on the life of Marathi stage and film actress Hansa Wadkar. Smita Patil delivered a remarkable performance in the titular role, supported by a stellar cast including Amol Palekar, Anant Nag, and Amrish Puri. “Bhumika” intricately examined the life of a film actress navigating the complexities of her public persona and private identity, exploring themes of self-discovery and fulfillment.
These four films—“Ankur,” “Nishant,” “Manthan,” and “Bhumika”—established Shyam Benegal as a leading figure in Indian art house cinema. His reputation was further solidified when he collaborated with Shashi Kapoor, who entrusted him with projects for his home production. Each of these films garnered critical acclaim and numerous awards, including National Awards, cementing Benegal’s status as a cinematic pioneer.
In 1978, Benegal directed “Junoon,” adapted from Ruskin Bond’s novel “A Flight of Pigeons,” set against the backdrop of the Indian Rebellion of 1857 and produced by Shashi Kapoor. Another film, “Kalyug,” again followed with Shashi Kapoor as the producer, depicting a modern retelling of the Mahabharata. It featured Raj Babbar, Rekha, and Shashi Kapoor in pivotal roles. While “Junoon” won the National Film Award for Best Feature Film in Hindi, “Kalyug” received mixed reviews and was deemed average by critics. He continued to explore diverse themes with “Aarohan” (1982), featuring Om Puri and Deepti Naval, showcasing his innovative storytelling.
In 1983, Benegal released “Mandi,” a satirical comedy based on a short story by Ghulam Abbas, which explored the lives of women working in a brothel amidst political machinations and real estate exploitation. The film, featuring Shabana Azmi, Smita Patil, and Naseeruddin Shah, won the National Film Award for Best Direction. Following “Mandi,” he created “Trikal,” set in Goa and exploring the complexities of a family transitioning out of Portuguese rule, and “Susman” (1987), which addressed the challenges of rural communities coping with rapid industrialization.
Also read: Mithun Chakraborty: “Talent is only secondary to click in films”
Benegal’s film “Antarnaad” (1993) examined the Swadhyay movement led by Pandurang Athavale, featuring Shabana Azmi. He then adapted Dharamvir Bharati’s novel “Suraj Ka Satvan Ghoda,” a reflexive narrative that interwove the lives of three women at different stages, produced by the National Film Development Corporation (NFDC).
In the mid-1990s, Benegal explored Muslim narratives with “Mammo” (1994), featuring Farida Jalal and written by Khalid Mohammad, Shama Zaidi, and Javed Siddiqui. It was followed by “Sardari Begum,” featuring Kiron Kher, Amrish Puri, and Rajit Kapoor, again written by Khalid Mohammad and Shama Zaidi. The third film of this trilogy, “Zubeida,” starred Karisma Kapoor, Rekha, and Manoj Bajpayee, continuing the exploration of complex female characters.
Shyam Benegal also tackled social issues in films like “Summer” (2000), which focused on the caste system in India, based on Harsh Mandir’s “Unheard Voices: Stories of Forgotten Lives.” His later works included “Hari Bhari” (2000), another NFDC project featuring Shabana Azmi, and “Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose: The Forgotten Hero” (2005), a high-budget film that, despite its ambitious scope, received mixed reviews.
Benegal’s film “Welcome to Sujanpur” (2010) was inspired by the 1977 film “Palkon Ki Chhaon Mein,” featuring Shreyas Talpade and Amrita Rao. He continued to explore diverse themes with “Well Done Abba” (2009), a remake of the 2007 Marathi film “Jau Tithe Khau.” His final film, “Mujeeb: The Making of a Nation” (2023), produced for the Bangladesh Film Development Corporation and NFDC, was a biographical portrayal of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, known as Bangabandhu.
Also read: Priyanka Zemse on ‘Me, Raani’ being in consideration for Oscars: “It was a sense of validation for my hard work”
In addition to his feature films, Benegal directed over 35 short films and television series, including the acclaimed “Yatra” (1986), commissioned by Indian Railways, which celebrated the spirit of Indian travel. His anthology series “Katha Sagar” (1988) showcased stories inspired by the works of prominent Indian writers, while his TV show inspired by Nehru’s “Discovery of India” offered profound insights into India’s socio political landscape. Other notable TV shows include “Amravati Ki Kahaniya” (1995), “Sankranthi” (1997), and the 2014 mini-series “Samvidhan,” which chronicled the making of the Indian Constitution, underscoring his versatility and commitment to meaningful storytelling.
Shyam Benegal’s extensive body of work not only reflects his artistic vision but also his unwavering dedication to addressing social issues through the lens of cinema, making him a pivotal figure in the landscape of Indian filmmaking. His films continue to inspire and provoke thought, ensuring his legacy endures for future generations.
Honored with the prestigious Dada Saheb Phalke’ Award in 2005, the highest accolade in the field of filmmaking, Benegal’s contributions to the arts were further recognized with the Padma Shri and Padma Bhushan, among numerous national and international awards. Born in Hyderabad and hailing from Karnataka, Benegal pursued his studies in economics at Osmania University and was notably a second cousin to the legendary filmmaker and actor Guru Dutt.
Throughout his illustrious career, Benegal served as the President of the Federation of Film Societies of India (FFSI) and was a distinguished jury member at the 31st Moscow International Film Festival. He authored three insightful books and played a pivotal role in various governmental bodies, guiding a new generation of filmmakers. His involvement with the National Film Development Corporation (NFDC) further solidified his commitment to nurturing talent in Indian cinema.
Also read: Shahid Kapoor calls his character in Deva ‘Dark, Menacing, And Vulnerable’
Benegal’s filmmaking style is deeply rooted in realism, characterized by a profound understanding of character development and social issues. His memorable characters from films like “Mandi,” “Ankur,” and “Samar” resonate with audiences, leaving a lasting impact. The narrative depth and influence of his longtime collaborator, cinematographer Govind Nihalani, are evident in the visual storytelling that complements his work in films like “Aakrosh” and “Ardh-Satya.” His ability to create rich, complex characters is a hallmark of his work, showcasing a keen insight into the human experience, which eventually inspired Govind Nihalani and Kundan Shah.
As a master storyteller, Benegal possessed an exceptional grasp of art and aesthetics, seamlessly integrating background scores and camera work to enhance the emotional resonance of his films. His technical proficiency was evident in the flawless execution of his narratives, which often highlighted the struggles of marginalized communities, working-class individuals, and exploited women. This dedication to portraying the realities of life for the underprivileged firmly established him as a pioneer of the neorealist genre in Indian cinema.
Benegal’s films are not merely artistic expressions; they are powerful commentaries on societal issues, imbued with a strong narrative framework and meticulous technical execution. His courage to explore the lives of the downtrodden and his commitment to social justice have made him a figure of inspiration for many. He transcended the role of a filmmaker to become a literary giant, a thespian, and a pillar of artistic integrity in the industry.
As a leader in storytelling, Benegal has cultivated a rich tapestry of talent within the cinematic community, nurturing actors, technicians, and filmmakers who admire him not only for his artistry but also for his character. His influence has opened pathways for serious cinema in India, encouraging audiences and creators alike to engage with meaningful narratives that reflect the complexities of society.
Also read: Raj Kapoor was the last of the great movie moguls in Indian cinema
Shyam Benegal’s films serve as a guiding force, illuminating the path for those who seek to explore the depths of human experience through cinema. His dedication to addressing pressing social issues through the lens of art has profoundly enriched the Indian film landscape, making it a more meaningful and reflective space. For countless filmmakers and enthusiasts, his legacy is a testament to the power of cinema as a vehicle for change and understanding.
The loss of such a monumental figure in Indian cinema at the age of 90 is not merely a moment of sorrow; it resonates as a profound and sombre reflection for a nation that prides itself on its cinematic heritage. Shyam Benegal’s legacy is one of artistic brilliance and social consciousness, and his absence leaves a significant void in the landscape of Indian filmmaking. His contributions will continue to inspire and guide future generations, reminding us of the power of cinema to illuminate the human experience and provoke thought in a world often overshadowed by superficiality.
Long live Shyam Benegal—a visionary filmmaker whose work continues to inspire and resonate, reminding us of the profound impact that cinema can have on society and culture. His contributions will forever be cherished, and his stories will continue to echo in the hearts and minds of audiences for generations to come.
(Girish Wankhede is a renowned Trade Analyst, Film Critic and a Film Marketeer.)
You may like
Shyam Benegal was the Showman of Parallel Cinema who dared to cast talented newcomers who later emerged megastars
The doyen Shyam Babu breathes his last
“I am a very proud son”: Prateik Patil Babbar on Cannes screening of mom Smita Patil’s film Manthan
Mujib – The Making of a Nation Review: Shyam Benegal’s film is an inspiring masterpiece!
Shyam Benegal receives standing ovation at the India Premiere of Mujib – The Making of a Nation
The trailer of Shyam Benegal’s ‘Mujib’ out, theatrical release on October 27,2023